Close Menu
  • Home
  • About The Institute
  • Research
    • Foreign Influence & Funding
    • Geopolitics & Global Conflict
    • Islamist Movements & Networks
    • Middle East & Foreign Policy
    • National Security & Intelligence
    • Religious Freedom & Persecution
    • Terrorism & Extremism
    • U.S. Politics & Policy
    • Faith & Biblical Research
  • Initiatives
  • Counteroffensive
  • Stay Informed
  • Donate

THE STORIES BEHIND THE HEADLINES

Get Ryan Mauro’s latest intelligence, investigations and analysis delivered directly to your inbox—connecting the events making news to the threats, ideologies and global forces shaping what comes next.

Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram
The Mauro Institute
Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram YouTube TikTok LinkedIn
Donate
  • Home
  • About The Institute
  • Research
    1. Foreign Influence & Funding
    2. Geopolitics & Global Conflict
    3. Islamist Movements & Networks
    4. Middle East & Foreign Policy
    5. National Security & Intelligence
    6. Religious Freedom & Persecution
    7. Terrorism & Extremism
    8. U.S. Politics & Policy
    9. Faith & Biblical Research
    10. View All

    EXCLUSIVE: US nonprofit caught funding Hamas operative

    January 7, 2026

    Left-Wing Dark Money Powerhouse Funded Group Linked to Holocaust Museum Protestors

    December 28, 2023

    Who is Funding Hamas? (America’s Voice video interview)

    December 7, 2023

    Left-Wing Foundations Funding CAIR

    December 5, 2023

    The Russian influence operations targeting Candace Owens and you

    June 2, 2026

    Is the Military Doctoring Reports on ISIS & Covering It Up?

    May 10, 2016

    National Security Highlights From First Democratic Debate

    October 14, 2015

    The Five Ways Iran Has Disarmed the West

    September 29, 2015

    Did CAIR Violate its Tax Exempt Status by Endorsing an Anti-Trump Protest?

    May 17, 2024

    Left-Wing Financiers Stand by CAIR After Pro-Hamas Remarks

    March 27, 2024

    The Muslim-American Community Must Denounce Hamas

    February 19, 2024

    CAIR Admits to Violating its Tax-Exempt Status

    January 29, 2024

    The Iran narrative on X is fake—And here’s who’s really behind it

    March 26, 2026

    The six ways Trump could respond to Iran —and the one MOST LIKELY to unfold

    January 29, 2026

    EXCLUSIVE: Minnesota group pushes borderless revolution, backs terror allies and violence against ICE

    January 27, 2026

    The Future of Hamas is Pretty Bleak (summary of a youtube podcast)

    January 10, 2024

    Iranian Spies Arrested Were Plotting Attacks on U.S. Soil

    August 23, 2018

    NM Tragedy: Could the FBI Have Saved the Boy?

    August 8, 2018

    Homeland Security Whistleblower: 10 Jarring Revelations

    June 7, 2016

    Prominent Islamists Blast NSA for Monitoring Emails

    July 10, 2014

    Will Trump Let the US Army Stand By While 100,000 Christians Are Killed?

    July 23, 2019

    Persecuted Christians Support Brotherhood Terror Act

    April 13, 2016

    Indonesia Destroying Churches as Islamist Influence Grows

    June 12, 2014

    Iran & David Duke Salute Presbyterian Church USA

    February 23, 2014

    Why the San Diego mosque shooting handed ISIS exactly what they want

    May 19, 2026

    Pro-terror activists were winning—until this audience flipped the script

    March 10, 2026

    EXCLUSIVE: The Violent Extremist Group Reportedly Linked to Renee Nicole Good

    January 9, 2026

    The Anti-Israel Left Now Wants to Target Cops

    April 15, 2025

    Will Congress finally force IRS action against CAIR?

    February 27, 2026

    Pro-Terror Extremist Voters in the U.S. Part 4: Pro-Terrorism Voters

    November 6, 2024

    Pro-Terror Extremist Voters in the U.S. Part 3: Third Parties

    November 6, 2024

    Pro-Terror Extremist Voters in the U.S. Part 2: Trump

    November 6, 2024

    Passover proven? Shocking archaeological evidence supports the Biblical Exodus

    April 1, 2026

    Alleged Discovery of “Real” Mt. Sinai Could Change the Middle East Forever

    August 14, 2009

    The Dark philosopher linking Alexander Soros and Zohran Mamdani

    July 30, 2026

    The Russian influence operations targeting Candace Owens and you

    June 2, 2026

    Why the San Diego mosque shooting handed ISIS exactly what they want

    May 19, 2026

    Passover proven? Shocking archaeological evidence supports the Biblical Exodus

    April 1, 2026
  • Initiatives
  • Counteroffensive
  • Stay Informed
  • Donate
The Mauro Institute
Home»National Security & Intelligence»NYPD Vindicated – Surveillance Targeted Potential Terrorists
National Security & Intelligence

NYPD Vindicated – Surveillance Targeted Potential Terrorists

By Ryan MauroFebruary 24, 2014No Comments5 Mins Read
Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr WhatsApp VKontakte Email
Share
Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest Email

Originally published by Clarion Project.

District Judge William Martini of New Jersey has dismissed a lawsuit against the New York Police Department for its intelligence-gathering in the state. The development is another vindication for the NYPD as it faces a campaign of misinformation from Islamists and their allies aimed at smearing the department’s anti-terrorism efforts.

The plaintiffs include a Muslim Brotherhood-founded group named the Muslim Students Association. Another is the Muslim Foundation, which has received hundreds of thousands of dollars from an Iranian regime front. They argue that the NYPD should pay them for damages resulting from its intelligence-gathering on them.

However, according to the judge, the only reason these plaintiffs can allege that they are suffering is because the Associated Press detailed the NYPD operations to the public. If they wanted to sue someone, they should have sued the Associated Press — but they aren’t, because the lawsuit isn’t really about damages. It’s about bashing the NYPD.

“This confirms the plaintiffs’ alleged injuries flow from the Associated Press’ unauthorized disclosure of the documents …The Associated Press covertly obtained the materials and published them without authorization. Thus, the injury, if any existed, is not fairly traceable to the city,” Judge Martini ruled.

He also concluded that the NYPD was not conducting surveillance on individuals and organizations just for being Muslim, as the NYPD’s critics constantly allege. Judge Martini said that the NYPD’s intelligence-gathering to prevent Islamic terrorism obviously requires some intelligence-gathering on Muslims.

“The police could not have monitored New Jersey for Muslim terrorist activities without monitoring the Muslim community itself…The motive for the program was not solely to discriminate against Muslims, but to find Muslim terrorists hiding among the ordinary law-abiding Muslims,” Judge Martini said.

The NYPD’s intelligence-gathering in N.J. was previously vindicated when Governor Chris Christie’s Attorney General concluded that its practices were legal. The conclusion came after Christie slammed the NYPD for its operations. Following the Attorney General’s determination, the Christie Administration formed a Muslim Outreach Committee with Islamist members, including a Hamas-tied cleric whose deportation is sought by the Department of Homeland Security.

The facts have consistently shown that the NYPD is not casting a wide net over Muslims in the hopes of nabbing a few terrorists. Its targets are chosen on concrete information. That is why the Department has won bi-partisan praise, with Democratic Senator Chuck Schumer endorsing Police Commissioner Ray Kelly to lead the Department of Homeland Security.

Media reports scathed the NYPD for spying on clubs for Muslim students, for example. Actually, the NYPD was investigating chapters of the Muslim Students Association that had a history of extremist activity like booking radical speakers. The NYPD also was blasted for keeping tabs on Imam Reda Shata, a “moderate” cleric. Actually, he is a supporter of Hamas.

Further, the NYPD was condemned for its collaboration with the CIA. An investigation was conducted and the Department was cleared. The CIA review found “no evidence that any part of the agency’s support to the NYPD constituted ‘domestic spying.’”

The NYPD is also being sued in New York City by six plaintiffs. The suit received significant media coverage, but the NYPD’s defense did not. The defense included disturbing facts about the plaintiffs that showed that the NYPD would have been guilty of negligence if it did not follow-up on these facts.

The scandal-seeking media then focused on the story that the NYPD had labeled some Islamic organizations and mosques as “terrorism enterprises,” opening them up to deeper investigation. The actual numbers showed how this was taken out of context.

The NYPD had 175 mosques in its jurisdiction, at the very least. Over a period of 10 years, only 10 were labeled as a “terrorism enterprises.” This was done in accordance with the revised “Handschu Agreement” guidelines, which state that protected speech could be recorded when there is reasonable suspicion that two or more individuals are supporting terrorism within the target enterprise.

That’s common sense. Vocally supporting terrorism is legal under the Constitution, but it still can and should be used in investigations and as evidence in trials. If someone says suicide bombings are permissible, it’s worth collecting that evidence even if that person cannot be prosecuted for the statement.

Not all Muslims buy into the myth that the NYPD is mistreating them. In March 2012, about 25 Muslim leaders came together in New York City to defend the Department. On December 9, 2013, the NYPD Muslim Advisory Council honored Police Commissioner Ray Kelly for his work with their community, praising it as a “model of cooperation.”

“The Police Department has demonstrated that Muslims stand equal to other citizens of NYC by cracking down on hate crimes … Due to the work of the Hate Crime Task Force, Muslim New Yorkers can sleep more soundly at night,” the Council wrote.

Yet again, the NYPD has been vindicated, but that won’t silence its opponents. For the Islamists, it was never about facts or financial damages. It was always about influencing policy and convincing Muslims that they are in need of a guardian.

Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr WhatsApp Email

Comments are closed.

STAY CONNECTED
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • YouTube
  • LinkedIn
  • TikTok

THE STORIES BEHIND THE HEADLINES

Get Ryan Mauro’s latest intelligence, investigations and analysis delivered directly to your inbox—connecting the events making news to the threats, ideologies and global forces shaping what comes next.

THE MAURO INSTITUTE

Independent research, public education and humanitarian action.

EXPLORE

  • The Counteroffensive
  • Research Library
  • Initiatives

CONNECT

  • Stay Informed
  • Invite Ryan
  • Donate

CONTACT

  • admin@ryanmauro.com
  • About the Institute
© 2026 The Mauro Institute
Privacy Policy
Designed by Wonder Creative Agency
Facebook X (Twitter) Instagram YouTube LinkedIn TikTok
  • Research
  • Contact
© 2026 Ryan Mauro. Designed by Wonder Creative Agency.

Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.