Originally published by Clarion Project.
We must hope that Kerry’s public contradictions of administration policy reflect of a behind-the-scenes debate.
The disastrous effect of the Obama Administration’s support for the Muslim Brotherhood appears to be seen by Secretary of State John Kerry. In recent months, he has twice contradicted the administration’s policy with public statements against the Brotherhood and in support of the Egyptian military.
On August 1, Kerry enraged the Brotherhood by justifying the Egyptian military’s overthrow of President Morsi.
“The military was asked to intervene by millions and millions of people, all of whom were afraid of a descent into chaos, into violence,” he said, adding that the military was “restoring democracy.”
Then on November 20, Kerry said that the Muslim Brotherhood had “stolen” the Egyptian revolution that first toppled President Mubarak. He said that the Brotherhood won the elections afterwards because it was “the one single most organized entity in the state.”
The Brotherhood characterizes itself as the democratically elected representative of the Egyptian people. Kerry’s powerful statement undermines the Brotherhood’s claim to legitimacy and echoes the criticism of its opponents.
The Obama Administration as a whole, however, stands against the military intervention and cut off some military aid to Egypt in response. The policy is pushing Arab countries allied with the U.S. into the arms of Russia and has alienated the Egyptian population.
A Zogby poll in July found that Egyptians’ confidence in the U.S. was at one percent and President Obama’s approval rating was at 3%. Over two-thirds of Egyptians said that the U.S. was too supportive of Morsi.
Kerry’s stance also differs from that of his predecessor. The State Department under Hillary Clinton provided election training to the Muslim Brotherhood ahead of the vote. William Taylor, the director of the State Department’s Special Coordinator of the Office of Middle East Transitions, defended it by saying, “As long as parties, entities, do not espouse or conduct violence, we’ll work with them.”
He further suggested that the name of the Muslim Brotherhood was creating unfounded hysteria. “We need to … judge people and parties and movements on what they do, not what they’re called,” he said.
In April 2012, Undersecretary of State Robert Hormats said the State Department was meeting with Brotherhood representatives to discuss how to help small businesses in Egypt. He argued that the Brotherhood is “very pragmatic” and understands “they need to deliver results.”
When the Muslim Brotherhood violated its long-held pledge not to pursue Egypt’s presidency, the Clinton State Department responded favorably instead of calling out the Islamist group on its dishonesty and hypocrisy.
The Department even instructed Customs and Border Protection not to conduct a secondary inspection of Brotherhood officials coming to the U.S., even though one of them was implicated in a child pornography investigation.
Secretary of State Clinton’s Deputy Chief of Staff was Huma Abedin, an official with multiple family members in Muslim Brotherhood positions. Abedin herself was the assistant-editor of an Islamist journal, where she worked alongside her family members.
She served as an assistant-editor of the Journal of Muslim Minority Affairs from 1996, the same year she became a White House intern, to 2008, when she became a senior State Department official. Reviews of the journal have found disturbing extremist content.
In the world of politics and diplomacy, public statements are just a hint of what is said privately. Kerry’s statements indicate he may be one of President Obama’s detractors when it comes to Egypt and the Muslim Brotherhood.
For the sake of the Western world and anti-Islamist Muslims, we must hope that Kerry’s public contradictions of administration policy are reflective of a behind-the-scenes policy debate.
Ryan Mauro is the ClarionProject.org’s National Security Analyst, a fellow with the Clarion Project and is frequently interviewed on top-tier TV stations as an expert on counterterrorism and Islamic extremism.